HVAC Repair or Replace: How to Choose


<< More From John C. Flood


By John C. Flood of VA

When your HVAC system seems to be malfunctioning, it can be challenging to determine whether a repair will resolve the issue or if replacement is the more prudent option. John C. Flood helps homeowners like you identify the difference between a fixable problem and a system that should be replaced.


SIGNS IT’S TIME TO REPAIR YOUR HVAC SYSTEM
If any of the following issues are present, the system can often be repaired:

      • Uneven cooling or heating.
      • Strange noises or smells.
      • Short cycling (system turns on/off rapidly).
      • Unresponsive thermostat.
      • Unit is under 10 years old and generally reliable.
      • Repairs are infrequent and relatively low-cost.

If only one or two of these issues are noticed, a professional repair may be sufficient.


COMMON REPAIRABLE ISSUES
Some of the most common HVAC problems that can be repaired include:

      • Faulty capacitor or contactor.
      • Clogged drain line.
      • Bad thermostat.
      • Minor refrigerant leak.
      • Worn electrical components.
      • Corrosion of metal parts.
      • Poor drainage.
      • Improper prior installation.

SIGNS YOU MIGHT NEED TO REPLACE YOUR HVAC SYSTEM
Sometimes, HVAC problems are beyond repair. Replacement may be necessary if:

      • The system is 12-15 years old (or more).
      • Repairs are frequent or increasingly expensive.
      • The system uses R-22 refrigerant (phased out).
      • Energy bills continue rising without increased usage.
      • Comfort levels throughout the home are inconsistent.
      • A renovation or energy upgrade is planned.

Modern HVAC systems offer improved energy efficiency, enhanced smart home compatibility, and more reliable performance, making replacement a more favorable investment in many cases.


COMMON REPLACEMENT-WORTHY ISSUES
The following problems usually require full replacement:

      • Cracked heat exchanger.
      • Failing compressor.
      • Major refrigerant leak in an older unit.
      • Obsolete parts in discontinued systems.

WHEN IT’S A CLOSE CALL — THE 50% RULE
Not all HVAC issues have a clear solution. If the cost of a repair is 50% or more of the price of a new unit, replacement is typically the more cost-effective choice. This rule is especially important when a unit is more than halfway through its expected lifespan, typically six years or older.

When in doubt, consult a trusted professional for an honest evaluation. Many companies, including John C. Flood, offer free estimates to inspect the system and provide recommendations for next steps.


John C. Flood is a full-service home services company specializing in air conditioning, heating, plumbing, and electrical services throughout the DMV.

With a focus on upfront pricing, 24/7 emergency service, and a team of licensed professionals, John C. Flood is a leader in the industry, dedicated to making home comfort and maintenance seamless and stress-free!

Connect with them today with a call (703-752-1251) or click: WebsiteFacebookInstagramTwitter.

#HVACSys